Brown’s speech – The turning point? Politics Decoded Conference Special by Garbo
A good speech…
Well, it was a very good speech… by Brown’s standards. And it has put the doubters in the background… for now. Brown is no Blair and he is no Cameron when it comes to public speaking, but yesterday he was better than the Gordon Brown we are used to dozing through. 
This was not a speech aimed at the electorate. It was not an attempt to turn the polls round over night. It was aimed directly at the party. The snipers. It was a speech that would reassert his authority and cut down any “novices†who were pretenders to his crown. And, to a certain extent at least, it has worked.
What of Miliband?
David Miliband has had a bad week in terms of being considered as Labour’s next leader. He is sitting squarely on the fence at the moment and Brown has been able to take coded pot shots at him. Miliband now knows that if he doesn’t make a move, if Brown does not step down, he may well see his dream of becoming Labour leader realised, but he may never realise the ultimate dream of becoming Prime Minister. Yesterday’s speech pushed him a step, a small step albeit, further away from becoming PM – and for that you have say Brown’s speech was a success.
A speech for the grassroots
Whether any of this will make a blind bit of difference in the polls it remains to be seen. After all, the policy he spoke of will appeal grassroots Labour supporters, not the electing masses. He spoke of more investment, more spending, more handouts and presumably therefore more taxation. But I suspect it won’t have done him any damage – and may well lift his ratings a little.
The Sarah effect
I feel I should make a small comment about the Sarah effect as everyone else is! It seems that every party in need of a bounce needs a Sarah. It work for the Republicans, and with Sarah Brown it seems to have done the trick for Labour. The bigger point here is that it is clear the public want more women in high profile position in politics. Brown’s speech yesterday will be remembered for the sound bite about novices and the appearance of Sarah Brown. Perhaps the other parties and Labour themselves should take note…
A week is a long time…
They say a week is a long time in politics and the conference weeks are no exception. Next week’s Tory conference will really decide what the electorate is thinking. Cameron could well sink the New Labour ship next week if he gets it spot on, or he could let Labour back in the game. We saw how he reversed his fortunes a year ago in Blackpool. He will have to score a monumental own goal to really cause a dramatic shift, but once the ball gets rolling…
A temporary ceasefire, not lasting peace
All in all Brown’s speech has summed up the Labour conference. It was an internal affair. An attempt to reunite and sort out some family issues. It was fairly low key and not a time for pomp or showing off. In that respect it has been a success. It was business like and has undoubtedly made Brown’s position more secure than it was a week or two ago. But for how long? You’d be a fool to think that the sniping and plotting has ended. The Tory conference and Glenrothes by-election could well open those healing wounds. I feel that this week has merely been a temporary ceasefire rather than lasting peace within the Labour party.
Article Series - Politics Decoded 2008-9 by Garbo
- Using the Tories for our own, slightly warped, enjoyment: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Should he stay or should he go?: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Time for a change: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Europe in Ireland’s hands: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- The Gambler’s Gamble Update: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- How Stalin became Mr Bean… Happy Anniversary Gordon: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- The FAQ of Great Britain: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Politics Decoded Extra: MEPs
- MPs and their expenses: A Politics Decoded weekend special with Garbo
- David Davis has failed: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Glasgow East – One last banana skin: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Summer Loving: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- What should Labour do next? Politics Decoded with Garbo
- If Gordon goes, then Labour must call a general election: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Labour needs to start governing and there is only one way to do that: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- In defence of the USA: by Garbo
- Boris Johnson and CCHQ – a match made in hell? Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Two nations divided by lame duck leaders: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- It is time for Brown to end this farce: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- JK Rowling and THAT donation: Politics Decoded Conference Special by Garbo
- Brown’s speech – The turning point? Politics Decoded Conference Special by Garbo
- This wouldn’t have happened under Campbell: Politics Decoded Conference Special with Garbo
- Tory transport policy: Politics decoded conference special by Garbo
- The end of the world as we know it? – Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Mandelson is back: Politics decoded by Garbo
- George Osborne does it again: Politics Decoded conference special by Garbo
- Reports of Labour’s decline are exaggerated: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Two forgotten men making very different comebacks: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- The Story of Lance Corporal Jack Mizon: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Changing George Bush for Barack Obama? Yes. We. Can. Poltics Decoded by Garbo
- Barack Obama’s Generation & the legacy we should be looking for – Politics Decoded by Garbo
- It’s time David Cameron’s Conservatives made a move: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- It is time the Good Men did something about Robert Mugabe: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- The Class of 2008 End of Term Reports – Grading Clegg, Brown, Cameron and all: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- The Tory Threat – Ken Clarke, David Davis and George Osborne: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Peace off you plonkers: Greenpeace’s Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Obama, Barack to the Future: A New Hope – Politics Decoded by Garbo
- British jobs for British workers: Gordon Brown’s rivers of blood – Politics Decoded by Garbo
- New Labour – where did it all go wrong? By Garbo
- Some MPs give the rest a good name, Norman Baker I salute you: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Barack Obama’s brush with failure: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Europe, Lisbon, the economy, opportunity and opportunists: Politics decoded by Garbo
- Enough with the blame game, what would you do? Politics Decoded by Garbo
- It’s not sleazy if no rules were broken. Well, the rules ARE broken: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Smeargate: Much ado about nothing – Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Labour’s last chance to save itself: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- The real race to No.10 starts tomorrow: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Brown makes another expenses mistake: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Brown should have gone a year ago and the whole party knows it: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Cameron to become the moral judge? Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Time to get invloved in politics: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Knee jerk reactions, European elections, scandals, politics and all that: Politics decoded by Garbo
- How to solve a problem like Europe Part One: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- How to solve a problem like Europe Part Two: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Tories and Labour have a miserable week and yet end up winners (of sorts): Politics Decoded by Garbo
















Not sure about a turning point, though Miliband this year is starting to look like Brown last year, indecisive and not sure which way to jump. I agree that it was a good speech by Brown standards, not apologising for who he was, and doing a better job than last year of spelling out his ‘vision’ – which turns out to be a worth ethic of fairness, duty, service and protection of the vulnerable.
The trouble for Brown is that the speech everyone really wants to hear is Cameron’s, after his performance last year. Brown needs to score more hits on the ‘performance is all it is’ critique of the Tories to get anywhere.
david-keen’s last blog post.."Who I am, What I believe"
I agree with you David. Miliband is in real danger of looking very indecisive and weak and he could well end up being Labour’s nearly man as Portillo was with the Tories.