It is time for Brown to end this farce: Politics Decoded by Garbo
Things have just changed gear
With less than a week to go until the start of the Labour party conference, the leadership debate has been ratcheted up a notch or two. After a very quiet summer, that led the BBC’s Nick Robinson to say the leadership debate was dead, things have really started to get going again. The feeling in the media is now not if but when will Brown go? However, there is still a fair distance to be run before Brown will be making his last stand, which is only making the position for the Labour party even more dangerous.
A weak and wounded leader
Labour are currently shooting holes into Gordon Brown but failing to land the fatal wound. It would be a disaster for the party if Brown were to somehow survive all this, after ripping itself apart and totally discrediting its leader only to have him lead them in to an election. They would be an unelectable laughing stock. Either the sniping stops now or Brown goes – and we all know the sniping will not stop.
What needs to be done?
It will take 71 Labour MPs to nominate the SAME candidate before a leadership election is forced. This is looking very unlikely at the moment with barely a dozen names out in the open so far and no obvious candidate. Most significantly, not one of these dissenters is from the cabinet – in fact, so far the cabinet have come out to back their leader. Yet it seems that the only way that Brown can be forced out is if his cabinet rebel. So who, if anyone, will make that move?
Miliband in danger
David Miliband, who was seen just a few months ago as the main protagonist, is now in danger of looking just like his leader – weak and dithering. Some say that he would do well to bide his time and wait until Labour lose an election before making his move. The theory is he is young enough and he would not want to take over a sinking ship anyway.
Piffle. The man started to sound out making a move and, like Brown and the election that never was, has now gone too far to not act. If Labour lose the next election they could well be out for quite some time – enough time for a new young thing to take the limelight away from Miliband. Even worse, if Miliband does not strike now I think his reputation will be damaged. He has been causing trouble behind the scenes but has not shown the cojones to do anything about it, so far at least - and time is running out.
Plenty of candidates
Of course, there are plenty of candidates who want to stab Mr Brown in the back. Hutton’s performance at the weekend was laughable in his half hearted attempts to back Brown. Harman would love a shot at the leadership – though I might add, it would be the kiss of death if she did become leader. Darling, you sense, is just one disaster away from becoming a loose cannon as are one or two others.
Harder than it seems
So what is needed is a credible candidate and strong support not only from the backbenches but also the cabinet. So easily said, yet so much harder to coordinate and realise. I still think Brown will go, but it is not going to be easy for those who want to push him. In fact, it may well be very hard indeed.
Do the dignified thing Gordon
And therein lays the danger: the longer this is dragged out, the more damage the party suffers and Gordon Brown should realise this. Politics should be about policy and saving the economy. Instead it is about the soap opera. The time has come for Brown to demand his party “put up or shut up†and force a leadership election himself – it is the only dignified solution to this ongoing problem.
Article Series - Politics Decoded 2008-9 by Garbo
- Using the Tories for our own, slightly warped, enjoyment: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Should he stay or should he go?: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Time for a change: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Europe in Ireland’s hands: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- The Gambler’s Gamble Update: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- How Stalin became Mr Bean… Happy Anniversary Gordon: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- The FAQ of Great Britain: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Politics Decoded Extra: MEPs
- MPs and their expenses: A Politics Decoded weekend special with Garbo
- David Davis has failed: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Glasgow East - One last banana skin: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Summer Loving: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- What should Labour do next? Politics Decoded with Garbo
- If Gordon goes, then Labour must call a general election: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Labour needs to start governing and there is only one way to do that: Politics Decoded with Garbo
- In defence of the USA: by Garbo
- Boris Johnson and CCHQ - a match made in hell? Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Two nations divided by lame duck leaders: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- It is time for Brown to end this farce: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- JK Rowling and THAT donation: Politics Decoded Conference Special by Garbo
- Brown’s speech - The turning point? Politics Decoded Conference Special by Garbo
- This wouldn’t have happened under Campbell: Politics Decoded Conference Special with Garbo
- Tory transport policy: Politics decoded conference special by Garbo
- The end of the world as we know it? - Politics Decoded with Garbo
- Mandelson is back: Politics decoded by Garbo
- George Osborne does it again: Politics Decoded conference special by Garbo
- Reports of Labour’s decline are exaggerated: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Two forgotten men making very different comebacks: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- The Story of Lance Corporal Jack Mizon: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- Change? Yes. We. Can. Poltics Decoded by Garbo
- Generation Obama & the legacy we should be looking for - Politics Decoded by Garbo
- It’s time the Tories made a move: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- It is time the Good Men did something: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- The Class of 2008 End of Term Reports: Politics Decoded by Garbo
- The Tory Threat: Politics Decoded by Garbo








Harriet might be more electorate-friendly than you give her credit for. For starters she’s right at the posh end of middle class, and she’s obviously worth a bob or two. This means that voters don’t feel too threatened, particularly as they know she sent her children to a private school.
Then of course it’s stating the obvious I know but she’s a woman. This brings in a few votes almost regardless; look at the reports of erstwhile Clinton supporters prepared to vote for Palin (can they really be true?).
She has that subtle hint of dominatrix that seems to attract the English male, and just enough of the harridan harpy about her to remind everyone of Maggie.
She certainly managed to sell herself to the Labour membership despite starting as a rank outsider in the deputy leadership election.
She remains a conviction politician which is considerably more than Gordon has managed.
She has a sense of humour
She’s a lot prettier than Gordon
Stephen’s last blog post..Birmingham bash
Ha ha! I can see from your blog you are a big fan of Harriet. I am sure there are plenty of people who like her too - after all she beat off the like of Alan Johnson to deputy leader. But I just think she is too lightweight. While she may well have the “Palin” effect, that is short lived and gimmicky politics - exactly what the Labour party need to avoid if they are not disappear into oblivion for ten years.
I have to say, the thought of Harman as a dominatrix figure makes me feel slightly ill and her performance in parliament has, bar one PMQs, been pretty substandard. While I have nothing against as a person, I just do not think she is up to the job of Labour leader nor PM.
But who knows - we might even get to find out, as she will be a strong contender I am sure.
I think we’ll just have to agree to disagree on this one!